Why Competence Is a Safety Issue, Not Just a Paperwork Exercise
When auditors raise findings against Clause 7.2 of ISO 45001, the organisation often responds by pointing to a training register. That register might be perfectly formatted, fully signed, and completely useless as evidence that workers are actually competent to do their jobs safely.
On this page
Competence in ISO 45001 is not about attendance. It is about capability. The standard asks whether the people doing work that affects OH&S performance have the knowledge, skills, and experience to do it without harming themselves or others. That is a much harder question to answer than whether someone sat through an induction.
This article walks through what Clause 7.2 actually requires, how auditors test it, where organisations consistently fall short, and what good looks like in practice. If you are a WHS Manager, an internal auditor preparing for an audit cycle, or someone studying for an ISO 45001 credential, this is the clause you need to understand properly.
What Clause 7.2 Actually Says
The clause is concise. ISO 45001 requires the organisation to determine the competence of workers whose work affects OH&S performance. It then requires the organisation to ensure those workers are competent based on appropriate education, training, or experience. Where gaps exist, the organisation must take action to acquire the necessary competence, then evaluate the effectiveness of that action. Documented information must be retained as evidence.
That is four distinct obligations packed into a short clause. Each one matters, and each one is auditable.
Determining Competence Requirements
Before you can assess whether someone is competent, you need to know what competence looks like for their role. This means defining, for each position that affects OH&S performance, what knowledge, skills, and experience a person must have.
The critical word in the clause is “determine.” The organisation must actively identify what is required. A generic job description that says “must have relevant experience” does not meet this expectation. Neither does a training matrix that lists course names without specifying what capability each course is supposed to produce.
Think about a scaffolder on a construction site. Competence requirements for that role might include a Construction Induction Card (White Card), a scaffolding licence at the appropriate class, site-specific induction, familiarity with the relevant Australian standards for scaffolding, and demonstrated ability to identify and report hazards. Each of these is specific and verifiable. That is the level of definition the clause is pointing toward.
Ensuring Workers Are Competent
Once requirements are defined, the organisation must ensure workers actually meet them. The clause offers three pathways: education, training, or experience. These are not ranked in order of preference. What matters is that the chosen pathway produces genuine capability.
This is where many organisations get into trouble. They treat training as the default response to every competence gap, regardless of whether training is the right tool. If a worker lacks competence because they have never done the task before, supervised on-the-job experience may be more appropriate than a classroom course. If a worker lacks competence because they have forgotten a procedure they learned years ago, a refresher might be appropriate. The organisation needs to think about what will actually produce competence, not just what is easiest to document.
Evaluating Effectiveness
This is the requirement that separates organisations with a genuine competence system from those with a filing system. After taking action to address a competence gap, the organisation must evaluate whether that action worked.
Effectiveness evaluation does not mean asking the worker if they enjoyed the training. It means checking whether the person can now do the task competently. That might involve observation, practical assessment, supervisor sign-off, a test, or some combination. The method needs to be appropriate to the risk involved. For a high-risk task, a tick-and-flick assessment is not going to satisfy an auditor.
Retaining Documented Information
The clause requires documented information as evidence of competence. This is the one area where most organisations have something, even if it is incomplete. Training records, certificates, licences, and assessment results all count. The question is whether they are sufficient, current, and linked to the specific competence requirements defined for each role.
Exemplar Global Certified Training ProviderRTP No. 310970What Good Competence Management Looks Like in Practice
Let me describe what a well-functioning competence system looks like across a few common workplace scenarios. These are the kinds of situations auditors encounter regularly.
High-Risk Work Licences
In Australia, certain high-risk work requires a licence issued under Work Health and Safety legislation. Forklift operation, crane operation, scaffolding, and work in confined spaces are examples. For these roles, the competence requirement includes holding a current, valid licence for the specific class of work being performed.
A good competence system tracks licence expiry dates, not just the fact that a licence was obtained. It has a process for renewing licences before they expire. And it verifies that the licence class matches the actual equipment or task. An auditor who finds a forklift operator with a licence that expired six months ago has found a nonconformity. An auditor who finds a forklift operator whose licence covers a different class of forklift than the one they are operating has found a potentially more serious one.
Competency Matrices
Many organisations use a competency matrix to map roles against required competencies and track the status of each worker. When done well, this is a useful tool. When done poorly, it becomes a false sense of security.
A useful matrix links each competency to a defined standard, shows how competence was assessed (not just trained), includes an expiry date where relevant, and is kept current. A matrix that shows every box ticked green for every worker in every role is a red flag for an auditor. It suggests the matrix is being maintained for appearances rather than accuracy.
Contractors and Visitors
Clause 7.2 applies to workers, and ISO 45001 defines workers broadly to include contractors and others under the organisation's control. This means competence requirements extend beyond direct employees.
A common weakness is that organisations have robust competence processes for their own staff but rely entirely on contractor self-declaration for people brought in from outside. An auditor will ask how the organisation verifies that a contractor's workers have the competence required to do the work safely on their site. “We assume the contractor manages that” is not a satisfactory answer when the work involves significant OH&S risk.
Good practice includes pre-qualification requirements that specify minimum competence standards, verification of licences and qualifications before work commences, and site-specific induction that covers hazards relevant to the contractor's scope of work.
How Auditors Test Clause 7.2
If you are preparing for an internal audit or a certification audit, understanding how auditors approach this clause will help you identify gaps before the auditor does.
Starting with Role Definition
An auditor will typically start by asking how the organisation determines which roles affect OH&S performance. This is a broader question than it might seem. Almost every role in an organisation affects OH&S performance in some way, even if only through compliance with safe work procedures. The auditor is looking for evidence that the organisation has thought systematically about this, not just focused on obvious high-risk roles.
From there, the auditor will select a sample of roles and ask to see the defined competence requirements for those roles. If no documented requirements exist, that is a finding in itself.
Testing the Link Between Requirements and Records
Once the auditor has the competence requirements for a role, they will look at the records for individual workers in that role and test whether the records demonstrate the required competence. This is where gaps become visible.
Common gaps include: training records that show attendance but no assessment outcome; qualifications that are relevant but expired; competence requirements that have been updated but records that have not been reviewed against the new requirements; and workers doing tasks for which no competence requirements have been defined.
For more on how auditors approach this kind of evidence-based testing, the article on how to audit competence in ISO 9001: records, matrices and evaluation covers similar ground that applies across management system standards.
Evaluating Effectiveness Evidence
This is often the hardest part to evidence. The auditor will ask how the organisation knows that training or other competence-building actions have worked. If the answer is “we check that people attended the course,” the auditor will push further.
Look for post-training assessments, supervisor sign-off records, practical observation checklists, or incident data that shows improvement in the relevant area. None of these need to be elaborate. A simple supervisor sign-off form that confirms a worker demonstrated the required skill before working unsupervised is far more credible than a training attendance sheet alone.
Interviewing Workers
Auditors do not just review documents. They talk to workers. A worker who cannot explain the hazards associated with their task, does not know what PPE is required, or is unaware of the emergency procedures relevant to their work area is telling the auditor something important about whether the competence system is functioning.
This is not about catching workers out. It is about checking whether the system produces the outcomes it claims to. If the training records say a worker completed a chemical handling course but the worker cannot describe the correct procedure for a spill, the records are misleading.
Common Nonconformities Against Clause 7.2
Based on real audit experience across a range of industries, these are the most frequently raised findings against this clause.
No Defined Competence Requirements
The organisation has training records but has never formally defined what competence is required for each role. Records exist, but there is no baseline to measure them against. This makes it impossible to demonstrate that workers are competent because there is no agreed standard to compare them to.
Training Treated as Equivalent to Competence
The organisation equates completing training with being competent. There is no assessment, no evaluation of effectiveness, and no mechanism to identify whether the training actually produced the required capability. This is a process gap, not just a documentation gap.
Expired Licences or Qualifications
Workers are performing tasks that require current licences or qualifications, but the licences have expired and no one has noticed because there is no system for tracking expiry dates. This is a particularly common finding in industries with mandatory licensing requirements.
Gaps for Contractors
The competence system covers direct employees adequately but has no equivalent process for contractors and subcontractors. Given that many serious incidents in Australian workplaces involve contractors, this is a gap with real safety consequences.
Effectiveness Evaluation Is Nominal
The organisation has a process for evaluating effectiveness but it consists of a post-training survey asking participants if they found the course useful. This does not evaluate competence. It evaluates satisfaction. These are different things.
The article on planning to achieve OH&S objectives under Clause 6.2.2 is worth reading alongside this one, because competence gaps often show up as a root cause when objectives are not being met.
Connecting Clause 7.2 to the Broader OH&S System
Competence does not exist in isolation. It connects directly to hazard identification and risk assessment. If your hazard identification process (Clause 6.1.2.1) identifies that a particular task carries significant risk, the competence requirements for workers doing that task need to reflect that risk level. Higher risk means higher competence requirements and more rigorous assessment.
It also connects to operational controls (Clause 8.1). Many operational controls rely on workers having the knowledge and skill to implement them correctly. A permit-to-work system only works if the people issuing and receiving permits understand what they are doing and why. A safe work method statement only controls risk if workers have read it, understood it, and are capable of following it.
And it connects to incident investigation (Clause 10.2). When an incident occurs, one of the first questions is whether the workers involved were competent to do the task. If competence records are inadequate, the organisation cannot answer that question confidently, and it cannot identify competence gaps as a contributing factor to the incident.
Understanding how roles and responsibilities interact with competence requirements is also important. The article on roles, responsibilities and authorities under Clause 5.3 of ISO 45001 covers the related expectations in that clause.
Exemplar Global Certified Training ProviderRTP No. 310970Building a Competence System That Actually Works
If your current approach to Clause 7.2 is not working, here is a practical way to rebuild it.
Start by mapping every role that affects OH&S performance. Be inclusive rather than exclusive at this stage. For each role, define the specific competencies required, not just the training courses. Include mandatory licences, qualifications, and experience requirements. Specify how competence will be assessed and how often it will be reviewed.
Then audit your current records against those requirements. Where gaps exist, address them with the most appropriate intervention, whether that is training, supervised experience, coaching, or something else. Build in an assessment step that actually tests whether the intervention worked.
Create a tracking mechanism that flags upcoming expiries and triggers review when roles change or new hazards are identified. This does not need to be expensive software. A well-maintained spreadsheet with conditional formatting for expiry dates does the job for many organisations.
Finally, make sure the system covers contractors and visitors in a way that is proportionate to the risks they face on your site.
Practical Advice for Internal Auditors
When you are auditing Clause 7.2 internally, resist the temptation to treat it as a document review exercise. The documents are a starting point, not the finish line.
Pick a handful of roles across different risk levels and trace the competence evidence end to end. Can you find the defined requirements? Do the records match those requirements? Is there evidence of effectiveness evaluation? Talk to workers and ask them to describe how they know they are competent to do their job. Their answers will tell you more than any training register.
Pay particular attention to recently changed roles, new processes, and areas where incidents have occurred. These are the places where competence gaps are most likely to exist and most likely to matter.
If you want to develop your skills in auditing support clauses like Clause 7.2 across OH&S, quality, and environmental management systems, the ISO 45001 Lead Auditor and Internal Auditor courses at Audit Workshop are designed to give you the practical auditing skills to test these requirements with confidence, not just the theory behind them.













