Why Auditors Rarely Hear What Auditees Actually Think
Most auditors receive feedback in one direction only. They assess, they find, they report. The auditee responds to findings and closes out corrective actions. And then the cycle repeats. What rarely happens is a structured, honest conversation about how the audit itself went from the auditee's perspective.
On this page
This is a gap worth addressing. Auditee feedback on auditor performance is one of the most underused tools for professional development in the ISO auditing world. When gathered properly and taken seriously, it tells you things that no training course or witness audit can replicate. It tells you how your communication landed, whether your questions felt fair, whether the audit added value or just created paperwork.
This article is for auditors who want to use that feedback deliberately, and for audit programme managers who want to build it into the system. The advice here is grounded in real audit practice, not theory.
What Auditee Feedback Actually Covers
Before you can use feedback well, you need to be clear on what you are asking auditees to evaluate. There are two broad categories that matter.
Audit Conduct and Interpersonal Skills
This covers everything to do with how the auditor behaved during the audit. Did they explain the purpose clearly at the opening meeting? Did their questions feel respectful or interrogative? Did they listen properly, or were they already writing while the auditee was still talking? Did they stay on topic, or did they wander into areas outside the agreed scope?
These are not soft, optional extras. Soft skills are increasingly recognised as core auditor competence, and auditees are the most direct observers of whether an auditor actually has them. A technically competent auditor who makes people feel interrogated or dismissed will get worse evidence, produce weaker findings, and leave the organisation with a negative view of the audit function overall.
Audit Value and Usefulness
The second category is about whether the audit added anything. Did the findings reflect real issues, or did they feel like technicalities? Were the observations useful, or did they state the obvious? Did the auditor demonstrate enough understanding of the organisation's context to make the conversation meaningful?
Auditees are not always right on this. Sometimes a finding feels unfair because it is uncomfortable, not because it is wrong. But when multiple auditees across multiple audits say the findings felt disconnected from what actually matters in the business, that is a signal worth investigating.
Exemplar Global Certified Training ProviderRTP No. 310970How to Collect Feedback That Is Actually Honest
The challenge with auditee feedback is that auditees often do not feel safe giving it honestly. If you are a third party auditor from a certification body, the auditee knows their certification depends on the relationship. If you are an internal auditor, the auditee may be a colleague or even a manager. In both cases, there is pressure to say things were fine when they were not.
Anonymous Surveys Work Better Than Direct Conversations
A short, anonymous survey sent after the audit closes is the most reliable method. Keep it to five or six questions. Use a mix of rating scales and open text fields. Rating scales give you comparable data over time. Open text fields give you the specific, candid comments that actually teach you something.
Sample questions worth including are:
- Did the auditor explain the purpose and scope of the audit clearly at the start?
- Did the auditor's questions feel fair and relevant to your work?
- Did you feel heard during the audit, or did the auditor seem to have already formed conclusions?
- Were the findings and observations explained clearly and supported by evidence?
- Did this audit help you identify something genuinely useful for your team?
- Is there anything the auditor could have done differently to make the audit more useful?
That last open question is where the most valuable feedback usually lives. Give people space to write freely, and some of them will.
Timing Matters
Send the survey within a week of the closing meeting, while the experience is still fresh. If you wait a month, you will get lower response rates and vaguer answers. If you send it before the audit report is issued, you risk people conflating their feelings about the findings with their assessment of the auditor's conduct. After the report is distributed but before corrective actions are due is usually the right window.
Make It Easy to Respond
A five minute survey that lands in someone's inbox gets completed. A lengthy questionnaire that requires logging into a portal does not. Respect the auditee's time. If you cannot get useful information in six questions, you are asking the wrong questions.
Reading Feedback Without Getting Defensive
This is where it gets uncomfortable. Feedback that says your questions were unclear, or that you seemed to have made up your mind before the interview started, or that the audit felt like a box ticking exercise, is difficult to receive. The instinct is to explain it away. The auditee was defensive. They did not understand the process. They were just unhappy about the finding.
Sometimes that is true. But not always. And the auditors who improve fastest are the ones who can sit with uncomfortable feedback long enough to ask whether any of it is accurate.
Look for Patterns, Not Individual Comments
One negative comment from one auditee after one difficult audit tells you very little. A pattern of similar comments across multiple audits tells you a great deal. If three different auditees in three different organisations over six months all say your questions felt like a trap, that is not a coincidence. That is a technique problem worth addressing.
Track your feedback over time. Create a simple log that records the audit, the auditee, the ratings, and any written comments. Review it quarterly. Look for themes. You are not looking for perfection. You are looking for recurring signals.
Separate Conduct from Outcome
Auditees sometimes rate audits poorly because they received a nonconformity they disagreed with. That is understandable, but it conflates two different things. When you review feedback, try to separate comments about the auditor's conduct and communication from comments about the findings themselves. If someone says the finding was wrong but the audit was conducted professionally, that is useful information. If someone says the finding felt arbitrary and the auditor never really listened, that is different information entirely.
Turning Feedback Into Specific Development Actions
Feedback without action is just data. The point is to use it to change something about how you audit. Here is how to do that in practice.
Map Feedback to Specific Audit Behaviours
If feedback tells you that auditees felt your questions were leading, go back to your question technique. Open questions are the foundation of effective audit interviewing, and if auditees feel steered toward particular answers, you may be using closed or leading questions more than you realise. Record yourself in a practice scenario, or ask a colleague to observe your next internal audit and give you specific feedback on your questioning style.
If feedback tells you auditees did not feel heard, look at your note taking habits. Many auditors write during interviews in a way that signals they have stopped listening. Consider taking fewer notes during the conversation and consolidating them immediately afterward. Your active listening will improve, and auditees will notice.
If feedback tells you the opening meeting was confusing, review your opening meeting structure. A well run opening meeting sets the tone for everything that follows. If auditees leave the opening meeting unsure of what is going to happen or why, the rest of the audit starts at a disadvantage.
Set One Specific Goal Per Audit Cycle
Do not try to fix everything at once. Choose one behaviour to focus on for the next three to five audits. Make it specific and observable. Not “be a better listener” but “wait three seconds after each auditee response before asking the next question.” Not “improve my opening meetings” but “confirm scope and confidentiality in plain language before moving to the audit plan.”
After those three to five audits, review the feedback again. Has the rating on that dimension improved? Have the written comments changed? If yes, move on to the next area. If not, the behaviour may be more ingrained than you thought, and you may need external input, such as a peer observer or a coach.
Use Feedback in Your Audit Log
If you are maintaining an audit log for certification purposes, auditee feedback is relevant evidence of your professional development. Note what feedback you received, what you changed, and what effect you observed. This is exactly the kind of reflective practice that certification schemes value, and it demonstrates something more credible than a list of courses attended.
Building Feedback Into the Audit Programme
If you manage an internal audit programme rather than just conduct audits yourself, you have an opportunity to make auditee feedback a systemic part of how your programme operates.
Standardise the Feedback Process
Create a standard post audit survey that all internal auditors use. This gives you comparable data across auditors and over time. You can identify which auditors consistently get high marks for communication and which ones consistently get lower marks on audit value. That information is useful for selecting and developing your internal audit team and for targeting your training investment where it will have the most impact.
Include Feedback in Auditor Performance Reviews
Auditee feedback should be one input into how you evaluate your internal auditors. Not the only input, and not weighted so heavily that one difficult auditee can derail an otherwise strong auditor. But it should be on the table alongside audit log data, finding quality, and report writing standards.
When auditors know their feedback will be reviewed, they tend to take the post audit survey more seriously. And when they see that the feedback is used constructively rather than punitively, they become more willing to engage with it honestly.
Share Anonymised Themes Across the Team
One of the most effective things you can do in a team of internal auditors is share anonymised feedback themes at a team meeting. Not attributing specific comments to specific auditors, but discussing patterns that emerged across the programme. If multiple auditees across the year said audits felt rushed, that is a resource or scheduling issue that affects everyone. If multiple auditees said they were unclear about what would happen with their responses, that is a communication gap in how all auditors explain the process.
This kind of shared learning builds a culture where feedback is normal, not threatening. And it produces improvement that no individual auditor working in isolation could achieve.
A Note on Feedback from External Audits
If you conduct external audits for a certification body or as a contract auditor, collecting auditee feedback is harder but not impossible. Some certification bodies have their own client satisfaction processes. If yours does, ask to see your results. If it does not, you can still ask informally at the end of a closing meeting whether the audit was useful and whether there was anything you could have done differently.
Some auditees will deflect. Others will give you something genuinely useful. The ones who say “actually, it would have helped if you had explained why you were asking about that particular record before we spent 20 minutes pulling it out” are giving you gold. Write it down. Use it.
The auditors who build strong reputations in the certification body world are almost always the ones who treat every audit as a learning opportunity. Auditee feedback, even informal auditee feedback, is a direct window into how your practice looks from the other side of the table.
Exemplar Global Certified Training ProviderRTP No. 310970What Good Feedback Looks Like in Practice
To make this concrete, here is a scenario. An internal auditor at a manufacturing company conducts quarterly internal audits across five departments. After implementing a post audit survey, she receives the following pattern over two audit cycles:
- Ratings for “questions felt fair and relevant” average 4.2 out of 5 across all departments.
- Ratings for “audit helped identify something genuinely useful” average 3.1 out of 5.
- Three written comments across two cycles say some version of “the audit covered everything in the checklist but did not really engage with the issues we are actually dealing with.”
That pattern tells a clear story. The auditor is technically competent and conducts herself professionally. But she is working through her checklist rather than engaging with the organisation's actual context and risks. The fix is not more training on ISO clauses. It is a shift toward process based auditing that starts with understanding what the department is trying to achieve before asking whether the management system supports it.
She sets a specific goal for the next audit cycle: spend the first ten minutes of each audit session asking the department head what their biggest operational challenge has been since the last audit, before opening the checklist. The feedback in the following cycle shows the “genuinely useful” rating climb to 3.9. The written comments shift to things like “this audit actually felt relevant to what we are doing.”
That is what feedback driven development looks like. Not dramatic transformation. Steady, specific, measurable improvement.
How Audit Workshop Supports Auditor Development
If feedback is telling you that your technique needs work, structured training is one of the most efficient ways to address it. At Audit Workshop, our courses are built around practical auditing skills, not just standard interpretation. Whether you are working through an Internal Auditor course or building toward Lead Auditor level, the training covers interview technique, evidence gathering, finding classification, and report writing in a way that directly addresses the gaps auditees most commonly identify.
Our courses are delivered by Dilawar Laghari, who has conducted over 500 external ISO certification audits across Australia, the Middle East, and South Asia. The advice in our training comes from real audit practice, which means it reflects the same challenges you are navigating when auditees push back, go quiet, or tell you the audit did not add value.
If you are ready to take your auditing practice to the next level, explore our training options at auditworkshop.com.













